Content provided as an educational volunteer effort of the
American Passenger Rail Heritage Foundation (APRHF), a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization.
Please help support the preservation and promotion of passenger rail heritage. Join the APRHF today! Website hosting made possible by our sponsors.
|TrainWeb Reports & Web Sites:||Featured Today||Past Highlights||Previously Featured||Slideshows||The Big Stories||Directory|
The Aristo 0-4-0 is a nice little engine but it has a major problem. On most units, the four driver wheels get dirty very quickly and when that happens, the thing doesn't run at all. Aristo has addressed this problem with a wheel change, see below. With clean wheels it pulls fairly well considering its light weight. It is quiet and smooth and doesn't derail often, at least on large radius track. I have had some difficulties with it picking the frog on 1200 series turnouts.
The Aristo 0-4-0 is apparently modeled after the Pennsylvania Railroad A5 Class switcher. The model matches the size and overall appearance of this class well.
The model is nominally 1:29 scale and scales out pretty close. The model has fair detail and runs smoothly and quietly as long as the wheels are clean. It will run a much faster than scale speeds. Switchers were not known for high speed operation, but this little bugger will do 100 mph if you crank up the track voltage.
The main weak point of the 0-4-0 is its wheels. They are some kind of casting and the behave similarly to the wheels on the Pacific, in other words, they get dirty REAL fast. I don't know what the specific problem is but they just sweep up crud and power pickup gets flaky.
You can improve the power pickup by wiring the tender across to the loco to add 8 more wheels of power pickup. This helps a lot, but the tender wheels are made of the same stuff and they get cruddy too.
Aristo sent me a set of new wheels for evaluation. Lewis Polk said that the wheels are made with the same process as the wheels on the new ball bearing truck diesel bricks. The wheels came assembled with the bushings/power pickups and the front one came already greased inside its gearbox. The old wheels are a chemically blackened casting with a high copper content (probably a bronze). I do not know the composition of the new wheels, but they appear to be anodized instead of blackened. The old wheels, especially the spokes are flat black in color. The new wheels are dark gray brown with a moderate sheen.
After 10 minutes of running, the anodization on the treads of the new wheels was substantially scrubbed. After an hour, it was gone. This did not seem to have any impact on the power pickup, which remained very steady the whole time. After an hour of running with the old wheels, the engine would have been essentially nonfunctional. With the new wheels, the headlight was not even flickering. The wheel treads are still shiny and clean without a hint of the nonconductive crud that used to coat the wheels.
I do not know Aristo's plans for providing the new wheel assemblies as replacement parts, but they ought to make them available. This is a significant improvement.
Wheel installation instructions.
The Slopeback Tender comes with a sound system installed. This system has been much derided, but under the right conditions it isn't too bad.
The system chuffs fairly well but that's all it does. The sound system relies on the Aristo PWC system to work properly. Without PWC, the sound system doesn't get enough voltage off the track to work and can howl, growl, or screech terribly at low speed. On pulse power packs (such as MRC packs) it will hum and buzz. With PWC, it may occasionally make awful sounds but only at very slow speed. Unlike the Pacific's Long Tender, there is no provision for connection of a battery to allow the pack to work without PWC.
The volume control for the chuff is accessed by lifting the coal load from the rear. The water hatch slides back to unlatch the coal load.
The chuff trigger is a Hall effect device mounted above a tender axle. A doughnut shaped magnet rides against a rubber roller on the axle. The Hall effect device is mounted next to the magnet. If the chuff isn't working right, make sure that the rubber roller is clean and that the Hall effect device is RIGHT NEXT to the magnet. Even when it is working, the chuff rate is about half of the prototypical rate of 4 chuffs/turn.
After the rubber roller gets old and hardens up some it doesn't provide enough friction to turn the magnet reliably. After much fussing and fiddling, I finally tried to renew the roller surface with a coating of contact cement, AND IT WORKED! Pull the wheelset with the roller from the truck by flexing the truck sideframe slightly and then paint a layer of contact cement on the roller. Rubber cement would probably work too. Let it dry for about an hour and reinstall the wheelset. I do not know how long this patch will last, but even if it fails after awhile, it would be easy enough to do it again.[ Top ]
The 0-4-0 comes with a smoke generator that is driven by an air pump in the left cylinder. The unit puffs smoke in time with the drivers. The pump can be a little stiff when new causing the engine to run unsteadily at low speed. However, after a few hours of running, the pump will loosen up and low speed operation will smooth out. If you should remove the shell, be sure to reconnect the plastic hose back to the smoke unit when the shell is replaced. You can easily see and access the hose by popping off the smokebox cover.[ Top ]
A Kadee #831 coupler can be mounted directly in place of the supplied Aristo knuckle coupler, however the rear step must be cut to clear the coupler box. Cutting right next to the step supports will provide enough clearance for running on 8' diameter curves. To accommodate 4' diameter curves, more of the step and the inside two step supports would have to be removed and new step supports fabricated from strip styrene.
A Kadee #831 can also be mounted on the front of the 0-4-0 directly by using the existing hole and a Kadee supplied screw. A couple of the black Kadee supplied shims might be required to set the coupler at the right height.
Installation of DCC in the 0-4-0 is a piece of cake. All the connections necessary are on the top of the frame so that only the shell needs to be removed. I installed a Digitrax DG580L crosswise across the rear of the lead weight with a piece of double back foam tape. This decoder also has a small heat sink screwed to it. Even though the engine is small, the decoder can get quite hot without a heat sink of some kind.
There are two terminals screwed to the frame inside the firebox. There is a red wire leading down from one and a couple of black wires leading down from the other. The red wire and one of the black wires go to the motor and must be disconnected. The red wire is easy, you'll have to make a measurement to determine which black wire to use. Once all three wires are off the terminals, use an ohmmeter to see which black wire has about 7 ohms to the red wire. Solder the other black wire back to the terminal it came from.
Solder the black decoder wire to the terminal where the red motor wire went. Solder the red decoder wire back to where the black motor wire went. Solder the gray decoder wire to the red motor wire. Solder the orange decoder wire to the black motor wire and insulate all the connections.
I also wired the headlight between the blue decoder wire and F0 (white). I cut the headlight wires from the loco wiring and insulated the cut ends of the loco wiring . The decoder wires will reach forward to the headlight wires. I also connected the firebox light to the decoder between the blue decoder wire and the brown decoder wire (F3) and programmed the FX function in the decoder to random flicker to simulate a flickering firebox.
The tender light is wired to the F0(R) function of the decoder.
The DCC signal on the track effected the stock 0-4-0 sound system a little. There is a slight buzz due to the DCC signal leaking into the sound system, but it is not very loud and it can't be heard from more than a couple of feet away. I expected worse. The buzz went away when I put a Dallee system into the tender.
Since track power is available all the time, the sound system may not shut down when the engine stops. You may have to tweak the engine forward or backward some to get the chuff to stop blowing. It may be possible to sense the presence of motor pulses and shut down the system when the pulse train stops. This might make an interesting future project.
Eventually the motor noise made by the DG580L got to me. Also it started to behave strangely sometimes so I changed it out to an MRC AD320 as an experiment since the 0-4-0 was so noisy. This inexpensive decoder ($30) makes almost as much noise as the Digitrax decoder, but at least it runs properly all of the time. The AD320 has only four function outputs, F0 (forward and reverse), F1 and F2. I wired the headlights, bell and whistle. I left the firebox light disconnected.
Since I had already installed DCC in the 0-4-0, I decided to try a Dallee steam sound system because it was relatively inexpensive, about $125 including an IR chuff sensor. Also the Dallee system integrates fairly well with DCC decoders. The Dallee steam sound system doesn't have the sound quality of the more expensive systems but it is good enough as long as the chuff rate doesn't get too high. At high chuff rates, the chuff simply fades away. Dallee claims that this is the way it supposed to be, but I would expect the chuffs to merge into a steady roar instead of fading away completely. The system that I choose was for a PRR K4 since it seemed to be the closest to the PRR A5 0-4-0 prototype. All the Dallee chuff sounds are the same, the only thing that differs is the whistle sound.
I have subsequently done an installation of a Soundtraxx Sierra in another slopeback tender. This system sounds much better and integrates with DCC well also, but it requires the addition of some additional parts. Integration of the Sierra and DCC is described in my Shay Tips page.
After the stock sound board was removed, the first order of business was to find a place to mount the Dallee board. The Dallee board just fit crosswise in the tender body so I cut a small piece of styrene and mounted it to the two posts that held the original board. The Dallee board was then stuck down to this piece of plastic with the supplied foam tape. This placed the Dallee board so that the controls on the board can be accessed through the coal load.
The Dallee board was wired to the power pickups in the tender and to the existing itty bitty speaker. The floor of the tender is clearly sized for a 2.5" speaker, but this little speaker is mounted instead. Dallee supplies only a 1" speaker (intended for use in HO) so I elected to retain the existing speaker. I'll get a better one later because the system clearly needs it. The horn and whistle command pins are wired forward to the decoder in the engine on two pins of a 5 pin Molex type connector. Two other pins share track power between the tender and the engine. The fifth wire is used to wire the rear headlight to the decoder. Power for the rear headlight is derived from two diodes connected to the power pickups in the tender. The two diodes simulate the blue wire from the decoder which I couldn't bring back to the tender because I ran out of pins.
The sound board can control the chuff rate based on motor voltage or it can use an external switch or optical sensor to sequence the chuff. Since I was short of pins already and couldn't bring the motor voltage back to the tender, I elected to use the Dallee #853 optical chuff sensor. This device projects an IR beam and detects reflections from alternating white and black surfaces. Since the tender wheel is almost exactly 3/4 of the size of the drivers, three white spots on the inside wheel rim result in a nearly correct 4 chuffs per driver turn. The optical sensor is fairly sensitive to distance from the wheel rim, too close or too far and it won't work. Fortunately, it fit nicely on the bottom of a truck. Eventually, I reduced the number of stripes on the wheel back to reduce the chuff rate so that the system had a hope of keeping up. It now chuffs twice per tender wheel turn or about three times per driver turn.
I had another problem with the Dallee that I found annoying. It would blow the whistle for no obvious reason at random times. I had this same problem in the RS-3 installation, so I think that the sound system is at fault. In any event, to solve this problem I installed an optoisolator and the problem went away. The bell didn't have the same problem, but if it starts to flake out, I'll isolate it too.
This little loco has now had three different DCC decoders installed in it. The original Digitrax DG-580L failed and got flakey. Also the low PWM frequency caused an enormous amount of motor noise. It was replaced by an MRC AD320 decoder which also made a lot of motor noise. The noise was just too much for me so I installed a Zimo MX65S/N decoder. This one switches at 16 kHz and is nearly silent. It also worked better overall than either of the two previous ones. There were no changes required to the Dallee sound installation.
The Zimo MX65S is an upscale decoder. It has a 3 amp average capacity, plenty for this loco, and back-emf motor control. The 0-4-0 had a tendency to run away on downgrades so the back-emf control helps keep the loco speed a little more constant. The MX65S will do just about everything that any other decoder will do except it does not have special effects on the function outputs.
As delivered, the Zimo decoder needs a considerable amount of programming to get it working properly. When I first fired it up, the engine ran terribly. The Zimo comes set to a low PWM frequency with very high gain in the back EMF control. I needed to change the back EMF setting (CV58) to about 128 (decimal) and set CV9 to 0 to get the engine to run smoothly and quietly. It also needed tweaks to the start, mid and max voltages. The 0-4-0 tends to run really fast, so it is desirable to set the max speed to about 128 (decimal) as well with a mid point set at about 60 (decimal) to control the maximum speed of the loco.
The Zimo decoder went in pretty easily, the only hassle is function wiring. The function connections are a dual row of pins that you have to count to locate. A ribbon cable with an appropriate connector was supplied by Tony's Train Xchange, but since I had color coded wires already in the loco, I cut the ribbon quite short and spliced into it. Unused wires in the ribbon were capped off with a short length of shrink tube.
Zimo numbers their functions differently from the Digitrax, Lenz and NCE "standard" that I am used to. The table below lists the connections to the decoder along with the Digitrax function numbers and the wire colors that I used. The color column really has meaning only to me but I figured that recording them here would help me the next time I dug into the loco.
|Actual Function||Zimo Pin||Zimo Function Name||Digitrax Function Name||Wire Color|
|Firebox Light||13||Function 4||F3||Brown|
|Not Used||9||Function 5||F4||N/A|
|Not Used||12||Function 6||F5||N/A|
|Not Used||8||Function 7||F6||N/A|
|CLICK HERE FOR THE FULL CATEGORY DIRECTORY|
Visit our Rail Magazine promotion trading partners: (Click here to add your print rail magazine.)
|TrainWeb Reports & Web Sites:||Featured Today||Past Highlights||Previously Featured||Slideshows||The Big Stories||Directory|
Newsletter | About Us | Contact Us | Advertise With Us | Silver Rails Country for Train Enthusiasts
View TrainWeb.US Stats | Page updated:12/22/2018 | Version 2018l22b | Links | ©2015-2019 NordiLusta, LLC