CAR IDENTIFICATION
Sometimes we're asked how we know what car is in a photo since the number can't be readily seen. Here's the text of identifying one of the cars above:
"OK - I realize that this is a 'stump the chump' issue, but since the first time you asked me to ID this car back on April 12th 2000, I did a little more homework.
Simply, the shot is at Sparks NV during March 1971, so this was during the final chapter of Espee's transcon SP / UP 'Overland' service. By the final few years Espee had dropped so many runs that the original assignments for the domes were scattered to the wind.
This train in the picture is really the UPRR's 'City of San Francisco' as the 'Overland' was combined with the UP train during 1968.
Now back in April I was under the impression that this was the SP 3603 as cars #3601 through 3603 were assigned to the 'Overland' (in fact you have that jpeg from the Dorn book of SP 3601 in full fluting and UPRR colors).
However, Frailey's 'Trains in Twilight' (excellent book!) claims that equipment was a free for all at the end, and this is 'THE END' Baby!
From March to the May 1st 'Amtrak Day' anything with semicircular wheels that would still roll would be sent out.
Thus, no way to tell which car it is?
NAW, it's the SP #3606!
How come?
Simple... it was the ONLY car that had its' 'Daylight' logo re-applied after the 1959 loss of the 'Daylight' colors! Retaining this logo after the `59 silver & red repainting, AND again!!!!!! after the side fluting was yanked off during 1969!
This was IT! The ONLY SP dome with the 'Daylight' logo left at this late date!
I was under the impression back in April that the scratches in the photo matched similar ones on the 3603, but these gouges are on the port side of the car (lounge first), where as the 3603's scratches were smaller, and on the starboard side!
Answer: SP dome #3606 on the Tri-weekly City of S.F. during March 1971, heading westward thru Sparks NV from Ogden UT where these cars were added and UPRR domes removed!
Ahhhhhh, I LOVE this stuff!
Phil 'VistaDohmen'
Memphis, TN. "
(and then to prove just how WRONG our 'experts' can be......)
I have a friendly disagreement with Phil re his "car ID" paragraph on the 3/4 dome page, re car 3606.
I have noticed that it appears as though the SP 3601 & 3606 may have been the only production 3/4 domes that were either built or re-sided with stainless steel pier panels. The other 4 cars seem to have painted steel pier panels.
The photo in question of the unidentified car on the 3606 page appears to show a painted pier panel - note different appearance of pier panel vs girder sheet. Then, in the Vallejo pictures after retirement, the 3606 clearly has the unpainted stainless pier panels. Another point is that the 3606 in all the other photos has all of the propane racks closer to the middle of the car, and the mystery car clearly has them partially under the 4 lower-level side windows.
With that in mind, I contend that the "mystery car" is in fact the SP 3602. See photo #10 of the 3602 series - "3602 as 9371 at Chicago 12/73 by Phil Sims". Note that the crease in the girder sheet and the undercar equipment, specifically the location of the propane racks, match perfectly.
Just a little fun on a slow day.
Jon Clark (new owner of the 3602)
|